#eIDAS #EUdi Cooperative feedback to eIDAS implementation regulation:

eIDAS | @jaromil: dyne.org: The EUDI archi­tec­ture ref­er­ence frame­work (ARF) is built on the eIDAS2 spec­i­fi­ca­tion, and its imple­men­ta­tion act has been recent­ly approved by rep­re­sen­ta­tives of EU’s mem­ber states. The Euro­pean Com­mis­sion has just rat­i­fied its adop­tion.

Jaromil/dyne kri­tisiert: https://news.dyne.org/the-problems-of-european-digital-identity/

1. Fair­ness – Gerechtigkeit: Eine einzige Instanz kann Iden­tität­snach­weise wider­rufen und damit den Zugang zu grundle­gen­den Dien­stleis­tun­gen block­ieren.

2. Pri­va­cy – Pri­vat­sphäre: Schwache kryp­tografis­che Ver­fahren gefährden die Pri­vat­sphäre und ermöglichen unter bes­timmten Bedin­gun­gen die Verknüp­fung von Iden­titäts­dat­en.

3. Secu­ri­ty – Sicher­heit: Abhängigkeit von Google und Apple sowie von poten­ziell angreif­baren Sicher­heit­skom­po­nen­ten in Smart­phones.

4. Scal­a­bil­i­ty – Skalier­barkeit: Ver­al­tete Sig­naturver­fahren verur­sachen unnötige Kom­plex­ität und erschw­eren die Nutzung im grossen Massstab.

5. Obso­les­cence – Ver­al­tung: Fehlende Berück­sich­ti­gung quan­ten­sicher­er Kryp­tografie gefährdet die langfristige Sicherheit.6. Method­olog­i­cal – Methodik: Ein sys­tem­a­tis­ches Bedro­hungsmod­ell hätte vor der Entwick­lung der Architek­tur erstellt wer­den müssen.

7. Stake­hold­er Engage­ment – Beteili­gung: Kri­tik von Fach­leuten wird unzure­ichend berück­sichtigt. Sozial- und Geis­teswis­senschaften bleiben weit­ge­hend aus­geschlossen.

Und wie würde ich argumentieren?
EUROPE. Seven Questions for the Seven Sins of European Identity.

On 9 Jan­u­ary 2025, Jaromil iden­ti­fied sev­en prob­lems with the Euro­pean Dig­i­tal Iden­ti­ty (EUDI). His cri­tique is tech­ni­cal­ly pre­cise and polit­i­cal­ly ambi­tious. He calls for greater fair­ness, pri­va­cy, secu­ri­ty, scal­a­bil­i­ty, future-proof­ing, and par­tic­i­pa­tion.

But what hap­pens when we con­front his cri­tique with our work on the social?

1. Sin – which cul­tur­al form is speaking?Sin is a moral con­cept through which guilt, respon­si­bil­i­ty, for­give­ness, and social order can be observed. It has a long and con­tra­dic­to­ry his­to­ry with­in Euro­pean cul­ture. Jaromil uses the term rhetor­i­cal­ly. What would be inter­est­ing is to ask what func­tion this rhetoric per­forms with­in his tech­ni­cal cri­tique. Why sev­en sins? Why not sev­en con­tra­dic­tions, sev­en dis­tinc­tions, or sev­en unex­am­ined assump­tions? What does his argu­ment gain and lose through this par­tic­u­lar form?

2. Dig­i­tal – what is being dis­tin­guished from what?

In 1967, Paul Wat­zlaw­ick, Janet Beav­in, and Don Jack­son dis­tin­guished between ana­log and dig­i­tal com­mu­ni­ca­tion in their fourth axiom. This is not the same dis­tinc­tion we use, draw­ing on Luh­mann and Dirk Baeck­er, to observe the cul­tur­al forms of lan­guage, writ­ing, print­ing, and com­put­ing. Pre­cise­ly for this rea­son, we must keep them dis­tinct. A shift in the dom­i­nant medi­um of com­mu­ni­ca­tion does not sim­ply change tech­ni­cal instru­ments. It changes the con­di­tions under which com­mu­ni­ca­tion can sta­bilise itself. What does this mean for #soc? Which pre­vi­ous­ly improb­a­ble forms of social order become prob­a­ble?

3. Iden­ti­ty – why the human being, of all things?

For cen­turies, Euro­pean phi­los­o­phy has exam­ined the assump­tions under­ly­ing its own con­cep­tions of the human being. The visu­al arts exper­i­ment­ed with per­spec­tive and rep­re­sen­ta­tion. Coper­ni­cus dis­placed the Earth from the cen­tre of the cos­mos. The Catholic Church defend­ed and trans­formed its claims to inter­pre­tive author­i­ty. Fol­low­ing the rup­ture of civil­i­sa­tion in the twen­ti­eth cen­tu­ry, Ger­man-lan­guage phi­los­o­phy in par­tic­u­lar once again ques­tioned what hap­pens when human beings are sub­sumed under unam­bigu­ous cat­e­gories. Adornos con­cept of the non-iden­ti­cal belongs to this context.These his­to­ries are not iden­ti­cal. But they make a com­mon ques­tion acces­si­ble: Why does a Euro­pean infra­struc­ture so read­i­ly per­pet­u­ate the con­cept of unam­bigu­ous iden­ti­fi­a­bil­i­ty?

4. Cypher­punks – which free­dom is being defend­ed?

Jaromil crit­i­cis­es cen­tral­i­sa­tion, inad­e­quate cryp­tog­ra­phy, and depen­dence on Google and Apple. His alter­na­tives open up pos­si­bil­i­ties for dis­trib­uted con­trol. This matters.But are cypher­punks there­by defend­ing an autonomous indi­vid­ual who exer­cis­es sov­er­eign con­trol over their iden­ti­ty? Or do their tech­ni­cal meth­ods make it pos­si­ble to sep­a­rate com­mu­ni­ca­tion from sta­ble per­son­al identification?The sec­ond pos­si­bil­i­ty would be con­sid­er­ably more inter­est­ing for our work. And we should not pre­ma­ture­ly assign Jaromil to the first posi­tion. His pro­pos­als for selec­tive dis­clo­sure and decen­tralised revo­ca­tion mech­a­nisms deserve clos­er exam­i­na­tion.

5. Cyber­gr­rrrls – which pos­si­bil­i­ties had already been recog­nised?

In A Cyborg Man­i­festo (1985), Don­na Har­away ques­tioned the bound­aries between humans, ani­mals, and machines. In 1991, VNS Matrix inter­vened with a cyber­fem­i­nism that recom­bined bod­ies, gen­der, lan­guage, and tech­no­log­i­cal networks.These approach­es are not sim­ply iden­ti­cal to the cypher­punk move­ment. They might even con­tra­dict it. After all, the sov­er­eign, self-con­tained indi­vid­ual is by no means the only con­ceiv­able foun­da­tion of freedom.What hap­pens when com­mu­ni­ca­tion no longer has to be tied to an unam­bigu­ous body or a per­ma­nent iden­ti­ty? Which new forms of belong­ing, com­mit­ment, and respon­si­bil­i­ty become pos­si­ble? And which new depen­den­cies emerge?

6. Pow­er – which arrange­ments become infra­struc­ture?

This is where we apply #TheS­taub­Ber­nascon­i­Ma­trix.
- Arrange­ment: How are the pos­si­bil­i­ties of com­mu­ni­ca­tion struc­tured?
- Access: Under what con­di­tions do con­nec­tions become pos­si­ble
- Legit­i­ma­tion: How is the link between iden­ti­ty and social par­tic­i­pa­tion jus­ti­fied?
- Enforce­ment: How are these struc­tures sta­bilised, con­trolled, and trans­formed?

These four dimen­sions are not cri­te­ria for moral eval­u­a­tion. They make it pos­si­ble to observe rela­tions of pow­er. A decen­tralised iden­ti­ty archi­tec­ture may dis­trib­ute the pow­er of enforce­ment while con­tin­u­ing to make iden­ti­fi­ca­tion a pre­req­ui­site for access. In that case, one of Jaromils prob­lems would have been addressed with­out answer­ing our ques­tion about arrange­ment.

7. EUROPE – which futures are being fore­closed?

The Euro­pean Union invokes Euro­pean val­ues and tech­no­log­i­cal sov­er­eign­ty. At the same time, it is design­ing an infra­struc­ture whose start­ing point is the iden­ti­fi­ca­tion of nat­ur­al persons.This is not a log­i­cal con­tra­dic­tion. Soci­eties require reli­able forms of attri­bu­tion in many sit­u­a­tions, includ­ing claims, oblig­a­tions, and lia­bil­i­ty. The ques­tion is why this should lead to an over­ar­ch­ing iden­ti­ty archi­tec­ture.

#TheLuh­man­n­Map allows us to observe, at the lev­el of #soc, how com­put­er cul­ture changes the con­tin­gency of social forms. #TheS­taub­Ber­nascon­i­Ma­trix allows us to inves­ti­gate how these pos­si­bil­i­ties are arranged, made acces­si­ble, legit­imised, and enforced through rela­tions of power.This shifts the object of our cri­tique: from the secu­ri­ty of an iden­ti­ty infra­struc­ture to the ques­tion of why pre­cise­ly this infra­struc­ture emerges from the pos­si­bil­i­ties of a new cul­tur­al form.

The Open Ques­tion

Jaromils sev­en sins could be tech­ni­cal­ly reme­died. A secure, decen­tralised, quan­tum-resis­tant, and par­tic­i­pa­tive­ly devel­oped EUDI is conceivable.Would that solve our problem?Not nec­es­sar­i­ly. But elim­i­nat­ing unam­bigu­ous iden­ti­fi­ca­tion would not elim­i­nate pow­er either. It could gen­er­ate new depen­den­cies, exclu­sions, and forms of con­trol that are dif­fi­cult to hold accountable.We there­fore have no rea­son to declare iden­ti­ty an indis­pens­able foun­da­tion of the social. Nor do we have rea­son to ide­alise the absence of identity.What inter­ests us is the ques­tion of which oth­er social pos­si­bil­i­ties become avail­able with com­put­er cul­ture – and how we can exper­i­men­tal­ly trans­late them into infrastructure.Not search­ing for the next identity.Observing the pos­si­bil­i­ties of the social.

Sources and The­o­ret­i­cal Ref­er­ences

1 Jaromil (2025), The Sev­en Sins of Euro­pean Dig­i­tal Iden­ti­ty: https://news.dyne.org/the-problems-of-european-digital-identity/
2. Wat­zlaw­ick / Beav­in / Jack­son (1967), Prag­mat­ics of Human Com­mu­ni­ca­tion; see also Wat­zlaw­ick / Beav­in, Some For­mal Aspects of Com­mu­ni­ca­tion: https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764201000802
3 Adorno (1966), Neg­a­tive Dialec­tics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_Dialectics
4 Don­na Har­away (1985), A Cyborg Man­i­festo: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Cyborg_Manifesto
5 VNS Matrix (1991), A Cyber­fem­i­nist Man­i­festo for the 21st Cen­tu­ry: https://vnsmatrix.net/projects/the-cyberfeminist-manifesto-for-the-21st-centuryThe con­nec­tion to #TheLuh­man­n­Map and #TheS­taub­Ber­nascon­i­Ma­trix is our own analy­sis, not a claim made by these sources.
6 #PlanD Q102014.xyz