eIDAS | @jaromil: dyne.org: The EUDI architecture reference framework (ARF) is built on the eIDAS2 specification, and its implementation act has been recently approved by representatives of EU’s member states. The European Commission has just ratified its adoption.

Jaromil/dyne kritisiert: https://news.dyne.org/the-problems-of-european-digital-identity/
1. Fairness – Gerechtigkeit: Eine einzige Instanz kann Identitätsnachweise widerrufen und damit den Zugang zu grundlegenden Dienstleistungen blockieren.
2. Privacy – Privatsphäre: Schwache kryptografische Verfahren gefährden die Privatsphäre und ermöglichen unter bestimmten Bedingungen die Verknüpfung von Identitätsdaten.
3. Security – Sicherheit: Abhängigkeit von Google und Apple sowie von potenziell angreifbaren Sicherheitskomponenten in Smartphones.
4. Scalability – Skalierbarkeit: Veraltete Signaturverfahren verursachen unnötige Komplexität und erschweren die Nutzung im grossen Massstab.
5. Obsolescence – Veraltung: Fehlende Berücksichtigung quantensicherer Kryptografie gefährdet die langfristige Sicherheit.6. Methodological – Methodik: Ein systematisches Bedrohungsmodell hätte vor der Entwicklung der Architektur erstellt werden müssen.
7. Stakeholder Engagement – Beteiligung: Kritik von Fachleuten wird unzureichend berücksichtigt. Sozial- und Geisteswissenschaften bleiben weitgehend ausgeschlossen.
Und wie würde ich argumentieren?
EUROPE. Seven Questions for the Seven Sins of European Identity.
On 9 January 2025, Jaromil identified seven problems with the European Digital Identity (EUDI). His critique is technically precise and politically ambitious. He calls for greater fairness, privacy, security, scalability, future-proofing, and participation.
But what happens when we confront his critique with our work on the social?
1. Sin – which cultural form is speaking?Sin is a moral concept through which guilt, responsibility, forgiveness, and social order can be observed. It has a long and contradictory history within European culture. Jaromil uses the term rhetorically. What would be interesting is to ask what function this rhetoric performs within his technical critique. Why seven sins? Why not seven contradictions, seven distinctions, or seven unexamined assumptions? What does his argument gain and lose through this particular form?
2. Digital – what is being distinguished from what?
In 1967, Paul Watzlawick, Janet Beavin, and Don Jackson distinguished between analog and digital communication in their fourth axiom. This is not the same distinction we use, drawing on Luhmann and Dirk Baecker, to observe the cultural forms of language, writing, printing, and computing. Precisely for this reason, we must keep them distinct. A shift in the dominant medium of communication does not simply change technical instruments. It changes the conditions under which communication can stabilise itself. What does this mean for #soc? Which previously improbable forms of social order become probable?
3. Identity – why the human being, of all things?
For centuries, European philosophy has examined the assumptions underlying its own conceptions of the human being. The visual arts experimented with perspective and representation. Copernicus displaced the Earth from the centre of the cosmos. The Catholic Church defended and transformed its claims to interpretive authority. Following the rupture of civilisation in the twentieth century, German-language philosophy in particular once again questioned what happens when human beings are subsumed under unambiguous categories. Adornos concept of the non-identical belongs to this context.These histories are not identical. But they make a common question accessible: Why does a European infrastructure so readily perpetuate the concept of unambiguous identifiability?
4. Cypherpunks – which freedom is being defended?
Jaromil criticises centralisation, inadequate cryptography, and dependence on Google and Apple. His alternatives open up possibilities for distributed control. This matters.But are cypherpunks thereby defending an autonomous individual who exercises sovereign control over their identity? Or do their technical methods make it possible to separate communication from stable personal identification?The second possibility would be considerably more interesting for our work. And we should not prematurely assign Jaromil to the first position. His proposals for selective disclosure and decentralised revocation mechanisms deserve closer examination.
5. Cybergrrrrls – which possibilities had already been recognised?
In A Cyborg Manifesto (1985), Donna Haraway questioned the boundaries between humans, animals, and machines. In 1991, VNS Matrix intervened with a cyberfeminism that recombined bodies, gender, language, and technological networks.These approaches are not simply identical to the cypherpunk movement. They might even contradict it. After all, the sovereign, self-contained individual is by no means the only conceivable foundation of freedom.What happens when communication no longer has to be tied to an unambiguous body or a permanent identity? Which new forms of belonging, commitment, and responsibility become possible? And which new dependencies emerge?
6. Power – which arrangements become infrastructure?
This is where we apply #TheStaubBernasconiMatrix.
- Arrangement: How are the possibilities of communication structured?
- Access: Under what conditions do connections become possible
- Legitimation: How is the link between identity and social participation justified?
- Enforcement: How are these structures stabilised, controlled, and transformed?
These four dimensions are not criteria for moral evaluation. They make it possible to observe relations of power. A decentralised identity architecture may distribute the power of enforcement while continuing to make identification a prerequisite for access. In that case, one of Jaromils problems would have been addressed without answering our question about arrangement.
7. EUROPE – which futures are being foreclosed?
The European Union invokes European values and technological sovereignty. At the same time, it is designing an infrastructure whose starting point is the identification of natural persons.This is not a logical contradiction. Societies require reliable forms of attribution in many situations, including claims, obligations, and liability. The question is why this should lead to an overarching identity architecture.
#TheLuhmannMap allows us to observe, at the level of #soc, how computer culture changes the contingency of social forms. #TheStaubBernasconiMatrix allows us to investigate how these possibilities are arranged, made accessible, legitimised, and enforced through relations of power.This shifts the object of our critique: from the security of an identity infrastructure to the question of why precisely this infrastructure emerges from the possibilities of a new cultural form.
The Open Question
Jaromils seven sins could be technically remedied. A secure, decentralised, quantum-resistant, and participatively developed EUDI is conceivable.Would that solve our problem?Not necessarily. But eliminating unambiguous identification would not eliminate power either. It could generate new dependencies, exclusions, and forms of control that are difficult to hold accountable.We therefore have no reason to declare identity an indispensable foundation of the social. Nor do we have reason to idealise the absence of identity.What interests us is the question of which other social possibilities become available with computer culture – and how we can experimentally translate them into infrastructure.Not searching for the next identity.Observing the possibilities of the social.
Sources and Theoretical References
1 Jaromil (2025), The Seven Sins of European Digital Identity: https://news.dyne.org/the-problems-of-european-digital-identity/
2. Watzlawick / Beavin / Jackson (1967), Pragmatics of Human Communication; see also Watzlawick / Beavin, Some Formal Aspects of Communication: https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764201000802
3 Adorno (1966), Negative Dialectics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_Dialectics
4 Donna Haraway (1985), A Cyborg Manifesto: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Cyborg_Manifesto
5 VNS Matrix (1991), A Cyberfeminist Manifesto for the 21st Century: https://vnsmatrix.net/projects/the-cyberfeminist-manifesto-for-the-21st-centuryThe connection to #TheLuhmannMap and #TheStaubBernasconiMatrix is our own analysis, not a claim made by these sources.
6 #PlanD Q102014.xyz
